Discussion about this post

User's avatar
An observer from abroad's avatar

"Most fictional depictions of D.C. life show it as a super cynical place full of power-hungry schemers who don’t care about anything. This is a convenient device for a certain kind of thriller, but it’s extremely fake."

I want to see a high quality dramatization of the Iran-Contra affair. That was a very interesting time, with the CIA waging brutal covert wars in Central America, and the US President getting away with stuff that merited his removal from office. And the people who plotted and planned Iran-Contra were not power mad cynics but people who were willing to do terrible things for what they saw as the good of the US.

Expand full comment
Matt Hagy's avatar

> it rapidly became an article of faith in the Berniesphere that Sanders himself was wrong about this and the West Wing fandom in fact represented everything that was corrupt and bad about the Democratic Party

I think this faith results from the enticing simplicity of the corruption theory as well as its congruence with our intuition about human affairs. Our brains evolved in an environment consisting of small tribes where a few people could have a significant impact. We therefore naturally want to identify the key actors and their motives that conflict with our goals when society doesn’t function as we desire.

Hence these conspiracy theories have an intrinsic advantage in the “marketplace of ideas.” In contrast, the failings of well-intentioned bureaucrats requires understanding the management structure and incentives of complex, non-intuitive institutions.

Similarly, we struggle to comprehend the diverse interests and sincere beliefs of our country’s legislative representatives and their ever-shifting alliances. It’s hard enough for us to understand how individual people can have radically different models of reality than ourselves, yet alone project that onto large groups of people.

So we fall back on simple narratives centered on a few corrupt villains.

Expand full comment
318 more comments...

No posts