Discussion about this post

User's avatar
dysphemistic treadmill's avatar

To bang a drum that I have banged here before:

There are thousands of rape-kits lying untested all over the US. Some of those rapists are also murderers. There is a huge correlation between violence against women and other kinds of criminal violence. (It seems every time there's a deranged shooter, it turns out that there was a wife or gf raising red flags that were ignored by police.)

The criminal justice system has shown that it's unwilling to treat rape as a crime -- it's left on the books in case a black man rapes a white woman, but otherwise it's pretty much a dead letter.

But even if cops wink at rape, they should not overlook the huge resource of leads for cold-case murders that is sitting in those rape-kits. How many serial killers have also been serial rapists? The majority, maybe the vast majority.

Expand full comment
Aaron's avatar

Matt says: 'the general principle “it is good to catch people when they commit crimes” applies very broadly'.

I have not found this to be generally held opinion either among my liberal neighbors or when I take to my local Reddit to complain about crime.

Among my neighbors, the feeling seems to be that crimes are disproportionately committed by POCs or by people with issues that disproportionately affect POCs, and therefore efforts to stop crime are discriminatory.

On Reddit, the sample includes less of my liberal, semi-affluent, boho neighbors and more of the people I took honors classes in public high-school to escape. Among this cohort, the feeling seems to be, "fuck you, narc" or "I do what I want (for my benefit or on principle)".

As a rule-follower, I am genuinely puzzled by this sentiment.

I like to believe if I were to press them, these folks would all agree that it's wrong to murder someone...maybe. Beyond that, it gets dicey. I would wager many (though not all) would argue it's wrong to take someone's things without asking. Unfortunately, it is crimes related to the "common good" that I most want to see enforced and that are also the most contentious. As a result they only seem to be enforced in the most affluent sections of my city, and the rest of us are left to have our quality of life degraded in the name of Justice and Liberty.

Take this weekend's NYT story on the injustice of traffic stops: My take away from this article is that petty crime should not be stopped and that if a person is harmed while trying to escape the police, we should just cease to try to apprehend them...

Expand full comment
267 more comments...

No posts