Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John from FL's avatar

The entire discourse around this topic is so tortured and so concerned with not wanting to sound racist (in today's definition of that word) that reporters and even Matt can't come out and say what is true: The vast majority of people (including black people) want criminals (including black criminals) arrested and removed from their neighborhoods.

The disproportionate rate of crime in urban black neighborhoods has many causes, stretching back for generations. I care about those causes and their solutions. And I want criminals arrested, incarcerated and, if possible, reformed. There is no conflict between these two things.

Expand full comment
Marie Kennedy's avatar

I have so many frustrations with the discourse in this space. More than anything, I am frustrated with the obsession with mono-causality: that if someone is discussing how X contributes to a problem, it's a denial that Y is a factor

-It's possible that the national crime wave is the result of quarantine fatigue, distrust between citizens and police forces, police being under-resourced, and more

-It's possible that Trump's China-Covid language is a contributing factor to the anti-Asian crime wave but not the dominant one

-It's possible that Long held less respect for these women due to their ethnicity AND that it wasn't his primary motivation for killing them

On top of this, understanding the purity culture that seems to be the primary root cause of this killer's deranged mental state is actually profoundly enlightening. I encourage folks to check out David French's piece on it: https://frenchpress.thedispatch.com/p/why-the-atlanta-massacre-triggered As a reformed wokester, the parallels between purity culture and woke culture are profuse. The obsessive focus on one sin as primary over all others, the shame that comes when obsession with avoiding one set of thoughts leads to more of those thoughts (white bear paradox), the idea that lack of purity of thoughts is a permanently dehumanizing trait, etc etc.

(This deserves a far more in-depth, sensitive discussion that I do not have the time to complete here this morning.)

Expand full comment
249 more comments...

No posts