450 Comments
User's avatar
Kay Jaks's avatar

Wasn't the biggest deal that this also cut loans for nursing?? How does nursing not meet these standards

Helikitty's avatar

All of this is fine, but what I’d really like to see is federal student loans not charging interest as a first step. A lot of the math maths better when one ignores the time value of money, like a lot of students do when going into lower value programs.

Peter Gerdes's avatar

People don't like evaluating rules based on downstream effects, they want to signal their values and for many people on the left they have the value that education is a good in and of itself.

So yes, I'm on board but ofc you got roasted. It's exactly like objecting to affirmative action based on the idea that it does more to harm minorities than help them. Even if that's true (plausibly) as implemented in higher ed most people don't know about those numbers and they want to signal values and for all they know you are just coming up with that argument to excuse something you already believed.

It's a deeply unfortunate problem worsened by the democratization of political discourse.

alguna rubia's avatar

I do not buy the argument for cosmetology school being a worthwhile investment. Let's put "the trades" aside for a minute. Working as a waitress is obviously accessible for this demographic, requires no licensure or training, and makes more money per hour in many states. In many states, you can also apprentice at a workplace instead of going to cosmetology school, so you can make money while you train instead of paying for school. There are also a bunch of ways to make money from cosmetology skills without going to school in most states, like doing event makeup or traditional hair braiding. If the cosmetology school is genuinely good ROI, people should be perfectly capable of persuading a bank to give them a loan for it.

I personally struggle to see the value of a masters for people who are in the 10th percentile of their field. Shouldn't they just switch fields instead of taking on debt that won't even make more money than they could get with just a bachelor's?

James C.'s avatar

> people who are in the 10th percentile of their field.

Part of the issue is they don't realize/believe this, and no one wants to tell them. It's usually just easier to let the market do it, and it's best if we don't let them dig a deeper hole in the process.

alguna rubia's avatar

This is so true. This is part of the reason I much prefer the free public higher education model in many other countries, because the flip side of the fact that the school is free is that the government only has slots for as many people as they think they'll need for their economies and some people just get turned away from pursuing that degree. In America, there's pretty much always someone who will take your money to humor your hopeless dream; the federal government shouldn't be subsidizing that.

Vas's avatar

"There’s an unfortunate strain in American conservatism — also seen in the treatment of Medicare Advantage — that holds that it’s bad to spend money, but that as long as money is spent, it should be spent in a way that maximally aligns with predatory business interests."

I get thats how we see it, but I imagine a republican would put it differently. And one of my favorite things about Slow Boring is theyre willing to tell the Republican POV in a reasonable way. Even when thinking theyre wrong. (See, this entire article). So, whats the Republican take on why Republicans opposed the Obama rule?

Josh's avatar

My very lower case republican answer would be that there just isn't a legitimate argument that "not for profit" confers any sort of superiority in anything, including education institutions. The exemption of non profits plays a purely partisan hack job that undermines the legitimacy of the policy.

In my personal opinion any sort of federal student aid should be limited to government schools. Any and all forms of private university should require private funding. If you want Pell grants or government loans you should have to go to a state school.

JSM's avatar

So looking at some old articles from Reason (they aren't conservative but presumably have an ideological argument for the free market) and it seems like the arguments I've found were mostly about the unaccountability of federal bureaucracy making these rules (and that they should apply to regular universities too). Presumably a bootlegger and baptist thing once DeVos became Education secretary and instead of doing the free market idealist thing, she just gave the money back to for profit universities to reward the interest groups. https://reason.com/2012/07/05/for-profit-colleges-federal-money/ and https://reason.com/2016/09/19/obamas-anti-profit-crusade-targets-colle/

But honestly I think Republicans who actually care about issues (lol) came around to this view and that's why Trump is doing it now.

Edward Scizorhands's avatar

Higher trust in market forces to weed out bad ideas, when compared to government.

LaggedEffect's avatar

Just as an observation I think it is interesting that the people I know who are angriest that we don’t have a federal single payer health care system are also the most upset about federal meddling in higher education.

srynerson's avatar

Relatedly, I've noted here before that, on a Venn diagram, the circle of people who are in favor of "Medicare for All" or other forms of universal government-funded medical care almost completely overlaps with the circle of people whose publicly stated position is that there should be zero regulation of abortion and gender affirming medicine.

LaggedEffect's avatar

The way it will work is that we will never lose an election.

Noah Snyder's avatar

Part of the background for the (over)-reaction to this rule is that in fact Republicans are closing degree programs across the country for poorly-thought-through reasons. Here the legislature just shut down our Statistics major because the number of majors was too small, even though the Statistics classes are still well-attended by majors in other programs. They shut down every interdisciplinary science PhD program (e.g. you can't get a PhD in Mathematical Physics) again due to the small number of students even though there's zero costs to these programs (all the infrastructure is in one dept. you can just sub in some requirements from the other program when appropriate). None of this was the point of the legislation, which they thought was aimed at "useless" majors, but since Republicans no longer care about writing legislation carefully that's what happened.

It looks like as you say this particular poorly-thought-out program will have relatively little impact, but if it turns out that it does randomly close a bunch of degrees for some poorly-thought-reason, they're not going to change course.

John Smith's avatar

Eliminating a major doesn't necessarily eliminate the classes. Offering a degree carries other administrative costs not applicable to merely offering classes.

Aaron Erickson's avatar

I noticed the online reaction was shock and awe that as taxpayers we might want to get a better deal from this program + lots of bad faith representation of this program as "does trump approve of your major". The over-reaction to this seemed like it was almost manufactured by the kind of people who think it is somehow the responsibility of the US taxpayer to produce jobs for mediocre sociology professors.

Aphelini's avatar

The issue with this rule is that it puts in place both a mechanism to cut loans to low-performing majors AND for a school to decide to cut loans to low-performing majors if it decides on an overhaul. The second the government decides on a tougher metric than “beats earning with a high school degree,” many majors are toast. My field would be crushed by a rule about percent of graduates underemployed. We're panicking.

And you know what? To a degree, I don't disagree with a worse-case harsher metric. Yes, I'm one of the fortunate few with an assistant professorship. But I don't like how many of my classmates couldn't find a job. I don't like that many of the undergrads in my field have to get a job outside of the field and at the low end of what college grads make. I don't like that wages in my field have been depressed for decades because of the impression that there is no other employer for my field than academia. I definitely. Don't. Like. That all my senior colleagues are quick to dismiss job preparation as something my field just “doesn’t do.”

Maybe academia needs some pressure. Either prepare your students for the job market or don't lead them into a program just because they'll make more than a high school grad. They'll remember that when theyre making 60k and their STEM friends are making triple.

[This comment is about liberal arts degrees. I think social workers, for example, are necessary and that the best solution for that case is for the government (federal state local) to pay them more. ]

Alec Wilson's avatar

I realize in practice this will likely almost never apply, but how do these major-related rules handle undeclared kids and major switchers?

Josh's avatar

No idea and i doubt the writers thought through it that deeply. I do think student loans and grants should be capped at 4 years worth of college. Enlisting in the military gets you 8 semesters of school and the G.I. Bill is done. We give out grants and loans for 50% more than that with no service requirement.

Will I Am's avatar

"There’s an unfortunate strain in American conservatism — also seen in the treatment of Medicare Advantage — that holds that it’s bad to spend money, but that as long as money is spent, it should be spent in a way that maximally aligns with predatory business interests."

This is such a truth bomb. And oddly enough it tends to be the more "respectable" types of conservatives as opposed to Joe the Plumber MAGA types. My guess is that these "respectable" conservatives are most often the beneficiaries or are at least adjacent in some way to the beneficiaries of these predatory business practices.

For example: seemingly every conservative pastor's SAHM wife (including one of my cousins) works for some kind of MLM grift.

Grifting runs deep in conservative culture, and is bifurcated into lowbrow and highbrow types. Much like in the way that medieval lords exploited the labor of the peasntry, highbrow conservatives often see scamming the poor and working class beneath them as a kind of God-given right for their station.

None of the Above's avatar

Most of the people I've seen get into MLM stuff may have thought they were going to be doing the shearing, but they were actually the sheep. (What's that wonderful phrase from Don Quixote about going for wool and coming back shorn?)

Will I Am's avatar

I was blessed to have been innoculated early by an early 90's MLM that my dad got involved with. He had shown me some of the videos and I was so excited about getting involved with it when I turned 18 (I think I was 14 at the time), as it promised to make me a millionaire. My dad then told me the news a few months later, the whole thing was a Ponzi Scheme of some kind and the founder had fled the country with millions of dollars.

Funny enough, a favorite talking point of conservatives in my life has been how the Social Security Program is a giant "Ponzi Scheme", but when it comes to actual Ponzi Schemes these folks are like "Sign me up!"

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

I'm renewing my call for testing-based certification to replace education-based certification wherever possible.

Just let people take test(s) to prove they know cosmetology or elementary education or law or civil engineering or whatever. Do not require any education to take the test.

Ironically we already have exams for a lot of subjects, we just require education to even sit for the exam. Examples: CPA, bar, actuary, FE/PE.

Josh's avatar

I can only speak to the FE/PE and I don't think this is a good idea. You don't actually need a PE to hold a job as an engineer and the FE is basically useless. The kind of work a PE does really does need the education because they are the prerequisite to the years of working in your field under a PE before you are allowed to sit the exam. PE stamps are a very big deal and ensuring only the right people have them is why we don't have buildings and bridges that randomly collapse like other countries do.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

If the FE is useless make it a bigger exam (more realistically a series of exams) until it proves some level of knowledge comparable to that of a BS.

I have no problem with the PE still requiring years of employment as an engineer.

KB's avatar

The bar one is interesting to me because I'm a lawyer. My view is that law school prepared me better for being a lawyer than studying for/taking the bar exam, but apprenticeship would have been broadly superior to both.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

I'm a patent attorney. I generally agree law school taught me more than the bar, particularly legal writing. And working as an attorney taught me more than either.

That said, I think the answer isn't to keep requiring law school; it's to have a better bar exam. Rather than having a 2-3 day exam mostly on old common-law concepts and generic rules, have subject-specific exams testing real, relevant law. We could have exams on subjects like criminal law/procedure, corporations, wills & trusts, legal writing, property, oil & gas, and tax. Some of this would be nationwide and some state-specific.

The patent bar is a good example: it thoroughly tests actual real-life law in one narrow area. There's no legal education requirement to take the patent bar. There are for-profit commercial training companies for the patent bar, but because they're optional they sell a quality product at a competitive price.

KB's avatar

This makes sense to me. I'm a business immigration attorney, which is a niche within a niche. An exam specific to immigration law would have some value in weeding out charlatans and improving client confidence. The current system (requiring surface-level knowledge of many areas of law, none of which are relevant to my practice) does neither.

Liz's avatar

I struggle with this one simply because yeah, policy-wise, I agree. There is a lot of bureaucratic tape here that is no good for students and is a gross incentive for schools. I also know who this is intended to target: lot of professions dominated by women. I'd rather reform permitting and predatory "schools," alas.

Aphelini's avatar

Here's a genuine question I'm asking myself as a female professorin a likely-to-be-impacted field: wouldn't it be better if women went into fields where they made more money? Often substantially more in a STEM field or a corporate job with stock options? Are women really being served well by degrees that will leave them chronically underpaid in shrinking industries compared to their undergrad peers?

Liz's avatar
Oct 5Edited

Everyone would be better served by going into these jobs purely from a money POV but, also: comparative advantage is a thing (I am a good lawyer, would be a bad engineer and, at minimum, a lesser engineer than most). But additionally, I don’t think that it’s necessarily sub-optimal for people to be in these roles just because higher paying ones exist. The world wants cosmetologists and some people want to be cosmetologists. That’s fine and I’m less interested in how we get these folks to become doctors or architects than I am in letting them be enterprising, and I think one way to do that is to reduce the amount of licensing required that creates this impression you need a special school or badge in the first place.

The loan thing to me is a feint because it’s not the squeaky wheel, at least not any more than student loans generally are used to subsidize bloated ‘academic’ pursuits, and I tire of fiddling with carrots for students instead of sticks for fraudulent or misleading institutions.

My cynical opinion here is that the administration is less interested in that latter paragraph and this is part of a pattern of decisions intended to limit women’s options such as they exist today (not how we want them to exist) and funnel them back into family creation and parenting.

Josh's avatar

Maybe but it seems like the requirements for all the special badges and certificates comes entirely from the left side of our political spectrum. Growing up there was always at least a few women in my parents wider friend circle that gave haircuts and such out of their kitchens. These women made money and didn't need to run an entire business architecture for what is largely a low paid field. The vast majority of hairdressers work for supercuts wages not expensive hair boutique wages and no amount of licensing reform will change that.

None of the Above's avatar

Can you unpack why you think it is targeted at women?

Chris Brandow's avatar

I wonder if making it apply to all nonprofit colleges fails the “creating too much unnecessary bureaucracy” test.

James's avatar

I can't speak so much for America but at least here in Britain there is an unspoken truth that the main purpose of Masters programs for a lot of universities is fleecing students from the developing world and China who have a middle class background and can't get into domestic universities. Not great but everyone involved knows what they're doing (the overseas students are aware they are just going for a British university on their CV) and its a decent little "export" industry.

Andy Hickner's avatar

That is the case in the US too. The problem for universities in 2026 is how Trump & Co. are making it much harder for international students to stay here, renew their visas, etc resulting in horror stories of students being sent back to China before they finish their last semester of courses.

My sense is that the Chinese students are mostly going into STEM master's, while poorly-informed/deluded domestic students (mostly female) dominate MSW, MLIS, and other non-STEM programs.

SamChevre's avatar

In the US, the foreign students are getting what they pay for - which is a US work visa, not an education. (I'd like to change that, but ...)

Marc Robbins's avatar

I read the title of this post and immediately faced the question of how hard I should work to engage its substance. Bayesian analysis to the rescue!

Prior 1: 99% of everything the Trump administration does is bad.

Prior 2: 80% of Matt's bold claims are justified.

Chances that I will read this post deeply and find that it's convincing: 3.88%.

Outcome: I skimmed the post.

Helikitty's avatar

I haven’t laughed out loud at a sb comment in a while, thanks