423 Comments
User's avatar
Grouchy's avatar

While I agree with Matt, I’m guessing most hardcore environmentalists are also leftists, and the fact that Russia could wreak unlimited havoc is an argument for, not against.

Peter Gerdes's avatar

It's worth noting that if one doesn't think that battery and green tech is going to rise up (making this change a clear net win) then it's time to be giving up on reducing emissions and going all in on geoengineering. The worlds in which this bill isn't a net win are worlds in which we completely fail to limit our emissions enough to avoid huge climate change.

So either this is an environmental net win or we will need that energy to run whatever geoengineering effort we have to use to try to avoid the consequences of our failure to reduce fossil fuel usage.

Wolfy Jack's avatar

As an environmentalist, I think for both political and practical reasons the focus of the movement should be on decreasing consumption as well as renewable use, not attacking extraction or transport of fossil fuels..

It is a political loser, as well as ineffective. If they stop an oil pipeline like the Dakota Access brouhaha is hardly environmental if stopping it just means that oil gets shipped by rail tanker which is less safe.

But I think subsidies for renewables and nuclear are much more effective especially since we are in that window where costs are going down dramatically for solar and wind, but not quite enough that they are replacing fossils if you include battery backup for the intermittent nature.

Those subsidies make a lot of sense in bridging the period until renewables become the obvious choice just by cost.

The other thing is that just stopping oil or gas in the US just results in more OPEC production and also helps some bad actors like Russia, Iran, Venezuela.

ML's avatar

What’s the argument for decreasing over all consumption? I’m happy to drive an electric car for both economic and environmental reasons, but I don’t want to not drive to where I go on vacation. Likewise I’m not going to wall off part of my house to live in a smaller.

Wolfy Jack's avatar

Besides the individual value of simple living it is good for the planet, people, animals. Walling off your house isn't a suggestion, but in whatever way you reduce your carbon footprint you might be making life better for future generations.

I assume you believe global warming is real and potentially hazardous.

Falous's avatar

To try to be generous against mt nature I chose to understand this as energy efficiency purely rather than plain no growthism

Falous's avatar

I finance RE.

We do not need subsidies for our RE. You are over-focused on generation in thinking.

What is needed is

* investment in the grid for expansion and modernisation at both Transmission and Distribution levels

* reducation in red-tape for the permitting of all of Genreation and Grid installs as delays for conn

* Federal strategy to bring a unified coherence to Grid as national infrastructure, something along the lines of the Eisenhower era effort to both spread the infra costs and to speed an **integrated** nationally and regionally connected build

Nuclear does need some support. Wind... well no need to play Don Quixote - US would need to get rid of Jones Act anyway to make Offshore viable.

Support money on electrification expanion - so more grid at all levels and modernisation / upgrade of existing.

Electrification will crush the hydrocarbons on a wide range of use cases if we have more grid, faster (and thus cheaper) build.

moving tech frontier out on storage nice too of course.

Wolfy Jack's avatar

Need is a hard word. I think incentivizing renewables will lower their cost or for that matter hybrids and EVs will lead to their sales.

Not that the other suggestions aren't needed, I trust that you are right.

but I think we can do both that and subsidize renewables. It is an important enough issue that we need to do a lot of things, for example tax advantages to build smaller better insulated houses.

Falous's avatar

Limited resources. There are not unlimited state budgetary resources.

I don't need subsidies on generation for onshore use cases. (offshore wind, I'd say get the other barriers out of the way - permitting, the stupid ass Jones Act etc).

Use them elsewhere where they are actually needed.

* Grid, grid, grid, grid, grid and more grid.

Budgets are limited. Focus the subsidies where they do more good. And that is grid (plus new tech, sure, but commercially viable as in PV, onshore wind, what is needed is not subsidies, it's grid grid grid grid - transmission and distribution - and getting the red tape out of the way.).

I finance this shit - I am making a statement contra narrow interest. Sure I will pocket subsidies if they're given but I am telling you your thinking is too 2015 and we are in 2026.

Grid. Transmission for long-distance, distribution. National program for integration.

Nick Magrino's avatar

It's funny to not explain the underpants gnome reference at all.

Seneca Plutarchus's avatar

More regulatory and planning failures in the Blue states. Short sighted failure to focus on cheap electricity (in fact actively sabotaging cheap energy through things like passing through high property taxes from Con Edision to their ratepayers) while trying to beat the drum on climate change.

"The home heat situation is even worse. New England is quite cold in the winter, and people often rely on heating oil (which, again, is dirtier than gas) or at times wood. It would be good to see more people switch to electric heat pumps, which are very efficient and will also let people cool their homes in the increasingly warm New England summers. Again, though, how attractive this is as an option is largely a function of the price of electricity."

Heat pumps strike me as lot of hat, little cattle. To function well in places like New England, they need to be installed deep into the ground to get even adequate heat in the winter, installations like that cost tons of money thanks to Baumolism and contractoritis which will only get worse as supply is tigher, they still need backup heat for real cold most of the time and you end up spending something stupid like $30 thousand dollars so you can save hundreds to a few thousand dollars a year (?). Congratulations, sounds like a government spliff is needed to drive the, I'm sure, very profitable adoption of these technologies.

It's like that electric vehicle cost chart, spend $10-$20k extra on your BEV so you can save maybe $1200 if you drive a lot and live in the right state.

There's other things you can be doing with your money.

Rick's avatar
Oct 7Edited

BEVs are more like $5–10k extra when new and about the same as a comparable gas car once 2–3 years old.

Seneca Plutarchus's avatar

“Without that federal offset, the actual out-of-pocket price premium for new BEVs over comparable gas vehicles has expanded back to roughly $8,000 to $15,000 for volume-market models.”

“Automaker Margin Compression: To prevent demand from collapsing, OEMs have expanded direct dealer cash, promotional financing (0% to 1.9% APR), and factory lease support, absorbing an estimated $3,000 to $5,000 of the vanished credit.”

The fact that the BEVs are heavily depreciating isn’t actually good for them, though.

Rick's avatar

What are these quotes from?

The depreciation works well for used car buyers who skip the steepest part of the curve and keep the car a long time.

Josh's avatar

Sure but it relies on a solid population of new car buyers willing to give them this windfall. The boon to used car buyers will only last as long as there are enough people ideologically committed to BEVs enough to accept that they are losing an extra 10-15k over the few years they own that car compared to a mild hybrid.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

I'm a BEV owner* and cost savings aren't a significant factor in why I like it, I would drive a BEV even if it cost more than pure gas or hybrid. The torque, low center of gravity, and lack of shifting in a BEV make for a pleasant driving experience and charging in my garage is extremely convenient.

*In a state where this is cheaper than hybrid or gas per NYT.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

Reminder to anyone who feels guilty about a high-emission lifestyle there is a startup you can pay to release sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere to increase Earth's albedo to reduce global warming.

They're called "Make Sunsets," I paid them to release 100 grams of SO2.

Helikitty's avatar

Doesn’t that do the acid rain?

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

Yes, it does eventually. Balloon releases are at 70,000+ feet in the upper atmosphere which maximizes the ratio of cooling to acid rain.

This is kind of a battle of the least-bad options. I consider a cooler earth with very slightly more acid rain a good tradeoff.

Helikitty's avatar

We could release it elsewhere, too, like over Russia, China, and the Middle East, where we don’t mind more acid rain!

Josh Berry's avatar

I think the suggested location is generally where it used to be from shipping lanes?

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

My guess is the acid rain is very evenly distributed (at least within the northern hemisphere). SO2 stays in the atmosphere for a very long time!

SO2 is a major part of why volcanic eruptions can cause cool weather for years.

Flavorful Josephus's avatar

"More Acid!" What a campaign message! 😆

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

"There are no solutions, only tradeoffs." -Sowell

Zac Hill's avatar

All of this is true and well-framed, without even getting into the broader issue of how substituting dirtier foreign fossil fuels for cleaner American fossil fuels mechanically reduces emissions while increasing affordability and disadvantaging geopolitical opponents.

859552's avatar

If oil and gas exports were banned, and we built the domestic refining infrastructure to never need to import any, wouldn't that be good geopolitically? Iran, Russia, etc. would lose all that leverage over America. We'd have a much freer hand. I get that less supply for Europe means Russia has more leverage over them, but with the current world order, isn't reducing leverage over America more important?

Sunder's avatar

This ignores that refineries are at the low end $3-5 billion, 3-5 year investments and the high end $20-30 billion, 7-12 years. No one is shelling out for a refinery unless they have guaranteed long term profits. And we wouldn't have a freer hand. We wouldn't be able to influence Europe because they get all their energy from Russia and Putin could do whatever he wants in Ukraine. And Middle East action would hurt our allies in Asia and Australia so we'd just be pissing people off and making it so the rest of the world decides they probably need to start forming trade blocs with China instead. Also if we aren't exporting, then it actually becomes less profitable to produce energy because there's no place for the surplus oil and gas to be sold to. Storage is expensive and so energy costs would probably be higher in a world where we ban exports and have the perfect amount of domestic refining capacity. Also we'd have to rebuild all our old refineries because they are not configured to refine US oil but middle eastern and Venezuelan oil. Oil comes in different compositions and part of the reason US refineries have been so profitable is because they could take Venezuelan oil which is sold cheaply as it's hard to refine and sell the refined products. Refined products are sold at the same price regardless of the crude cost so if you can buy cheap crude you can make a bigger profit on the difference than someone who is buying more premium, easy to refine grades of crude.

Falous's avatar

If you spent hundreds billions on refining assets (and decade timeline mind you) to achive less efficiency than trade, you get a worse economic system.

This entire leaving aside that hydrocarbon reserves are limited and diminishing in efficiency so hydrocarbon energy autarky would be a capital expensive economically ineffecient and eventually failed manouever.

So no, it's dumb. Like planning to shoot garbage at the sun.

Or one can look at electric economy and electrification as more efficient path (energy as well as capital and thus economy wise) for same level of infra investment.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

My gut instinct is this kind of huge trade barrier would be net-bad, even if it gave the US more geopolitical freedom.

It would be a huge impediment to economic growth (oil & gas is like 12% of US exports) and would severely harm some friendly nations (Canada supplies 52% of US oil imports and 99% of gas imports; Mexico supplies about 11% of US oil imports; Mexico, Canada, Japan, and Netherlands are major destinations for exported US oil and petroleum products).

Amber McCullagh's avatar

Big if there on building the domestic refining infrastructure! That only happens if exports of oil products are allowed (which was the case prior to the lifting of the *crude oil* export ban), and in that case, the policy is just a giant check written to refiners (mostly supermajors but also some independents). The true isolationist scenario would be to also ban exports of refined products, but now you're needing to build refining capacity with a more limited market and lower margins (and/or retrofit existing capacity that's built to take heavier crude than the US produces). Big capex numbers required, to say nothing of the environmental permitting.

859552's avatar

Yeah, I guess I was imaging a hypothetical scenario where after 911, we realized the power the Middle East has to raise American gas prices was a real impediment to having good foreign policy, so we built the refining capacity necessary for energy independence as industrial policy. So you're taking an economic hit by deviating from the free market, but accepting that it's worth it to achieve that goal.

Falous's avatar

It would not be worthwhile and would be in fact incredibly stupid, working at best for limited timespan.

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

I guess you’re imagining a situation in which the American oil market is just completely cut off from the world oil market, so that the price could be $60 a barrel in one and $120 a barrel in the other and there would still be no cross-shipment? That doesn’t seem like a realistic goal.

859552's avatar

You mean smuggling? Is it that easy to smuggle oil from America? It takes up a lot more space per dollar than cocaine. Or do you mean there's be too much political pressure from oil companies or Europe to repeal the export ban?

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

There’s already a worldwide industry set up in oil shipping, and customers of all sorts are used to the price stability it provides. Making them all deal with more volatility and preventing any of them from engaging with it just doesn’t seem like a plausible political achievement.

Amber McCullagh's avatar

This is more or less the case for US gas--not because exports aren't allowed but because the capacity is expensive to build and takes a long time. The impact, of course, is fewer people working in US gas production, and more importantly lower royalties for states and landowners, than would be the case if they could export as much as the world would bear.

Jeff E's avatar

I would appeal to climate activists this way. If all we needed to do was to stop emissions from growing, the "stop and slow everything" strategy would work.

But since we need to electrify everything, we absolutely need this grid permitting reform. What happens to the gas part of is pretty immaterial - that's only about whether we are going to be burning oil or gas on our way down - but the thing that absolutely needs to happen is this massive backlog of electrification projects needs to be able to move forward.

Dilan Esper's avatar

I think the Left assumed energy was going to be like tobacco, where they just cast the tobacco companies as villains.

But oil companies aren't tobacco companies. They sell a highly useful and needed product with some bad externalities, not a poison. So the analogy breaks down.

Falous's avatar

And energy is fundamental to the economy.

Tobacco is merely a consumer product.

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

Even more - tobacco is a consumer product that a large number of its consumers wish in some larger sense that they never consumed.

Falous's avatar

Yes - non-key non-fundamental and large percent of conumsers never used and always disliked.

More equivalent would be something like if somehow I dunno (to be really silly), meat calories were found to drive cancer but by age 60....

City Of Trees's avatar

The analogy would have worked better in the application of particulate air pollution that, like the most common form of tobacco consumption in smoking, was eminently rivalrous of a common pool good in breathable air to an immediately unpleasant degree. Greenhouse gases don't provide such immediate displeasure, so their externalities are not judged as harshly as the benefits that burning them provide.

Falous's avatar

Generally speaking the entire CO2 as polution is a bad framework for understanding CO2.

There is really fundamental difference between CO2 emission (and overall carbon & carbon dioxide) 'role' in the process and even in atmosphere versus say particulates as a combustion by-product or equally the model of the CFCs (the Ozone Hole driver)

It is just simply a bad template for action, notably in a context where one has different technological pathways and at same time CO2 itself while have a negative sideeffect for us as humans given what's best for our current society, are entirely part of a natural variation system (sure our throwing CO2 back into atmosphere is not per se natural but that CO2 was there before - and there have been natural episodes where volcanism etc have throw huge amounts back in - Planet is fine with this, our modern agricultural systems, not so much... this is correctly more about our convenience, not "pollution")

Helikitty's avatar

Btw, my husband and I are coming up on 3 weeks without cigarettes. We had the flu, didn’t smoke for a few days, and decided it prudent to hide the ashtrays and keep it going. Still vaping, of course, but I call it a win! We’ll see how long we can keep it going

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

My uncle managed to quit smoking cigarettes by switching to vaping and slowly reducing the nicotine content of the vapes he was using. He said the key was to recreate the experience of cigarettes as much as possible, he used a vape shaped like a cigarette and tobacco-flavored liquid.

n = 1 and you guys might already know this, my apologies if so.

Helikitty's avatar

Yeah, I use Vuse which is the e-cigarette style of vape. It’s what I already did in the car, at work, etc, and i can buy the cartridges at 7-11 (though I prefer getting them on the rez in bulk bc it’s way cheaper). My husband prefers the more traditional and less discreet style of vape. Yes, it would be nice to gradually reduce the amount of nicotine, my doctor would be happy!

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

That’s great! Best wishes keeping the trend!

(I gave up non-Substack social media a few years ago by not doing any during a weekend in Puerto Vallarta and then just keeping the streak going.)

lindamc's avatar

Congrats to both of you! In my experience this is the way to kick unwanted habits.

David's avatar

Great piece. The refusal among greens to acknowledge the global nature of the climate problem, and how that complicates solutions, is always so striking.

Greg Byrne's avatar

If you want to put oil companies out of the business of oil, then how can you oppose natural gas?? It's cleaner than oil, cheaper than oil, more plentiful than oil. The coal industry didn't collapse because of activism. It collapsed because other cleaner things got cheaper. Eventually, solar and wind and other renewables will be probably cheaper than gas. That's how it works!!

Falous's avatar

This is the key part: "The coal industry didn't collapse because of activism. It collapsed because other cleaner things got cheaper. Eventually, solar and wind and other renewables will be probably cheaper than gas. That's how it works!!"

Screaming and throwing paint on executives did nothing much but bringing levelised cost down to crush coal, that's killed them.

Electrification bring down the cost of getting electrons so that every long-hanging electriciation fruit is eaten is the path.

srynerson's avatar

Well, not to defend the theory, but there's historically not been a distinct "oil industry" from the "natural gas industry" -- oil and natural gas were typically produced together and it was generally the same companies handling extraction and most transportation/shipping for both. (I'm hedging with "historically" because I will acknowledge that with the shale gas revolution and other developments, there may be enough straight "gas plays" being developed to have companies that don't include oil as part of their portfolio of products at all.)

Greg Byrne's avatar

I said 'out of the business of oil'. I didn't mean out of business.

srynerson's avatar

Sorry, I misread that!

AnthonyCV's avatar

When I was working as a cleantech consultant, I was often the guy reminding (or worse, informing) people that actually solving climate change was going to require at least 10x-ing world electricity production, all from clean sources, which in practice means covering a total land area somewhere between South Korea and Egypt in solar panels. A few people heard that and agreed (at least directionally). Some heard it and concluded that could never be done for one reason or another. Most people just didn't want to hear it and refused to think about what it meant. The best reaction I got was "Wow that's a lot, but also not really that much?"

Seneca Plutarchus's avatar

Or you could build some nuclear plants instead of covering Egypt.

AnthonyCV's avatar

In practice, "You will need to build at least 40,000 large nuclear power plants" would get dismissed even faster by most of the people I've said this to.

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

It sounds a lot more plausible when you say “total land area equal to that covered by roads”.

AnthonyCV's avatar

Fair. Honestly we could do pretty well just by requiring all parking lots be covered with solar canopies. I see those occasionally in the southwest, but not often. Good for the cars too. All DER at scale requires grid upgrades to better manage omnidirectional power flows within distribution grids, which very few utilities are properly planning for.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

My office (Denver area) has solar covering part of the parking lot and it's great, it keep cars nice and cool.

That said, there are downsides to parking lot solar. It's expensive because the panels have to be up high and can't have a bunch of supports, for example.

City Of Trees's avatar

I'd imagine it also puts a higher risk of locking in the land use to a parking lot, which also has downsides.

srynerson's avatar

As an aside, there's an INS office in Aurora, CO that, at least as of a few years ago, had most of its parking lot covered by a solar array and I've wondered occasionally whether the current administration has ordered that ripped out . . . .

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

Yeah, that... seems achievable? There's a lot of low-value sunny land in places like the Sahara, US-Mexico border regions, and Australia.

Sunder's avatar

But also, you need transmission lines. And deserts arent devoid of life so you'll still need permitting reform to take advantage

Seneca Plutarchus's avatar

Plenty of places for nuclear plants that don't require long distance transmission or relocating industry.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

I'm very much in favor of nuclear, but at least within the US we can't seem to build it. We can build solar.

AnthonyCV's avatar

Yes, there is! Sadly most current energy demand is either in places where land is pricier because people live there, or for uses that need more water than the sunniest regions get. So you run into all the questions about, should we relocate industrial facilities? should we go to these places and build desalination, and long distance electrical transmission, and plants for producing various synthetic fuels for shippable energy storage? And then you get lots of ambitious projects that go nowhere because they're not embedded in a system that's ready for them, and people write off whole swaths of useful ideas.

If we manage to get cheap multijunction cells (which I have hopes perovskite will do in the 2030s) you can mathematically get pretty darn far in lots of cities with rooftop solar, home batteries/VPPs/EV+V2G/grid-scale-BESS, various-ways-to-time-shift-loads, dispatchable/seasonal waste gasification (municipal and ag waste), and reasonable grid upgrades. Maybe add some extra nuclear for baseload if you can, and definitely keep around any gas capacity you have for winter use (but upgrade to make plants more fuel agnostic). Then in the 2040s synthetic fuels will likely be at a point where they can actually replace the remaining gas demand at an affordable price with synthetic fuels.

Lots of hard problems. None intrinsically unsolvable. Each one solved slows climate change and buys us a little more time to solve then next one.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

I've thought for a while that Mexico should be blanketing the US border region with solar to fuel industry with cheap electricity and try to export electricity to the US.

lindamc's avatar

“Lots of hard problems. None intrinsically unsolvable. Each one solved slows climate change and buys us a little more time to solve then next one.”

Excellent post-it for all who want to actually address climate change!

gary's avatar

Now about the water problem in the Southwest?

AnthonyCV's avatar

Pre-empt near-century-old-agreements based on incorrect assumptions. Cap extraction and price by market. The rest can partly take care of itself, and otherwise make clear what else is needed. Obviously there are lots of reasons no one wants to do it, but it would work.

xxxx(I was mistaken about this, see replies) One of the most impactful things we can do, of course, is building more renewable power, since nationally about a third of water use is for power generation.xxxx

The next big water use is agriculture, which as you note is regional. And can be reduced by changing farming practices, to some degree. Also agrivoltaics can potentially reduce water demand somewhat, increase revenue, and leave yield largely unaltered for some crops, but are underexplored to date. And the bottleneck can be reduced with desalination, for any application that can't otherwise be ameliorated or moved. Which needs even more clean energy.

What won't work is what we often get now, which is obsessive focus on residential consumption, which takes way more money to save way less water.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

Denver just banned watering lawns due to our drought.

Agriculture is 88% of Colorado water use but only 12% of the state's economy.

At some point we just need to tell the farmers we're not doing this anymore.

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

12% of the state economy actually sounds relatively high!

AnthonyCV's avatar

It is, but also, if you target your water saving measures at literally anything else, you can only reduce the problem by <12%.

In order to get to water neutrality, Colorado will need to reduce total primary water consumption by by 25% or so, which means most of the reduction just has to come from agriculture, there's no way around that unless you plan to pipe in ridiculous amounts of desalinated water all the way up from the coast. Or if cities downstream do so, enabling Colorado to withdraw more from its rivers. Which could happen, if we managed water rights well and let people buy and sell water at appropriate prices.

Monkey staring at a monolith's avatar

I may be calculating it wrong, I used the most generous number for agriculture I could find for agriculture: " $47 billion annually

in economic activity" and divided it by state GDP.

https://content.leg.colorado.gov/sites/default/files/r23-286_agricultural_economy_in_colorado.pdf

Marc Robbins's avatar

How is that vast amount of water used for power generation? Are we talking large hydro (I.e., big dams)? If so, I thought that was snugly in the renewable group. If not that, please explain.

AnthonyCV's avatar

I'd actually like to withdraw that part of my comment. I hadn't realized just how large a fraction of the water use by thermoelectric plants comes from surface water and is then returned to the same source. Almost all, in most places. I edited my comment accordingly, thank you.

Dilan Esper's avatar

If we built enough solar and nuclear in California we could probably desalinate at scale....

Marc Robbins's avatar

Is lack of electricity really the limiting factor for desalination? Wouldn't we just hit the next ones -- vast amounts of brine, disrupting the oceanic food supply chain, massive industrialization along the coast?

Helikitty's avatar

Just pipe the brine to the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, it’s already a sacrifice zone. Or to the Great Salt Lake, which is declining, so I hear

AnthonyCV's avatar

There will always be a bottleneck. All physical systems have limits. Which ones hit when, and how hard, is an empirical question, and in this case yes, electricity hits first, and the other problems are reducible to a significant extent.

Edit to add: one question I have about this is: where are cities discharging their treated wastewater right now? My understanding is that it's usually back into the nearby surface water anyway. Only about 10-20% of industrial and residential water use is lost to evaporation. Why couldn't you colocate desal and mix the brine the est of the with the discharge? That would seem like step 1 of a plan to reduce this problem.

Caroline Sutton's avatar

Thanks guys for having really fascinating discussions on today's article.

To me, one of the most important terms when we talk about climate is conservation. As many of you know, that term is a very old one in the environmental movement, and its associated ideas may not always align with today's clean energy rollout. Matt has a fascinating piece about conservation here (it's one of my favorites articles about the environment) and it might be a good one to read if you want to go further with today's topic: https://www.slowboring.com/p/a-bolder-vision-for-american-energy

City Of Trees's avatar

A comment that I didn't make on that article (looks like because I was out of town at that time) is that conservation also has multiple meanings. There is the energy reduction angle, but there's also the conserving of wilderness for recreation. These types of conservationists can sometimes not be as revved up about AGW compared to other environmentalists, more so about water and other air pollution, and tend to be the most NIMBY of environmentalists--not just for fossil fuels, but also even applications like wind and solar that they see as too disturbing to the landscape.

Actual Marmot's avatar

Strip the provisions gutting the Endangered Species Act and Clean Water Act that apply to far more than just permitting and I might agree with you. As is, no way.

Kenny Easwaran's avatar

What do you mean, “apply to far more than just permitting”?

EC-2021's avatar

Oh, which parts of the bill do that?