Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Oliver's avatar

There is a somebody who decided to increase immigration in the 80s and 90s, but it wasn't Congress or the Executive, it was farmers and officials in border states who wanted labour that would work at wages below what Americans would demand and those who tolerared that illegality. A policy continued by Trump who still refuses to fine farmers and other employers who hire illegal labour.

earl king's avatar

Whether people like it or not, American business welcomed illegal immigrants. We could have stopped it anytime we wanted to by raiding businesses. Every single one of the lawn services that ply my neighborhood has Hispanic workers, largely illegal, I would imagine. We invited them to come to work; they got paid, and they send money home to their families.

Many are economic refugees. It is stupid that we don’t have a worker permit program at the border where companies can list jobs that Americans will not do. An experiment was run decades in the last century. I believe the job of picking strawberries was advertised at $20 an hour in the summer CA sun. People passed.

Either way, this is all moot at this point. America is not having babies; our birth rate crisis will consume us unless we allow immigration; our transfer programs will be affected. Meaning, as Americans age, there will not be enough workers to fund Social Security and Medicare. The number of workers will contract.

This may be good for displaced workers from robotics and AI, but overall, our stock markets and government funding depend on a growing population, business, and tax revenue. Well off Europeans are not interested in coming here. An article today in the Times outlines an 18% drop in foreign students, mainly in graduate programs.

What the Trump Administration has done has made America seem unwelcoming. Our racist VP, who feels Heritage Americans are the only ones who should have agency, is part of the Stephen Miller plan to Make America White Again.

America never was white, and by 2045 it will be a majority minority country. America is about immigration; we are successfully melting the population together (mostly) Muslims and Orthodox Jews, not so much. Our culture clashes with their religious values. But absent that, we are very good at incorporating immigrants of all sorts.

15 more comments...

Ready for more?