17 Comments
User's avatar
Thomas L. Hutcheson's avatar

"Conservatives reasonably believe that immigration should be selective, aimed at bringing over people who are most likely to make large positive economic cont

That's what non Conservative I want and I've seen zero interest by Republicans in this, which is not surprizing as most ceased beng conservative decades ago.

And anyone deserving asylum for being perseduted for their political beliefs is probably able to "make a large positive econmic contribution to the United States."

Oliver's avatar

What about people who were tortured in their home countries like Algeria or Egypt because they were outspoken Islamists or successionists. A large percentage of people who are persecuted for their beliefs have illiberal beliefs.

earl king's avatar

Whether people like it or not, American business welcomed illegal immigrants. We could have stopped it anytime we wanted to by raiding businesses. Every single one of the lawn services that ply my neighborhood has Hispanic workers, largely illegal, I would imagine. We invited them to come to work; they got paid, and they send money home to their families.

Many are economic refugees. It is stupid that we don’t have a worker permit program at the border where companies can list jobs that Americans will not do. An experiment was run decades in the last century. I believe the job of picking strawberries was advertised at $20 an hour in the summer CA sun. People passed.

Either way, this is all moot at this point. America is not having babies; our birth rate crisis will consume us unless we allow immigration; our transfer programs will be affected. Meaning, as Americans age, there will not be enough workers to fund Social Security and Medicare. The number of workers will contract.

This may be good for displaced workers from robotics and AI, but overall, our stock markets and government funding depend on a growing population, business, and tax revenue. Well off Europeans are not interested in coming here. An article today in the Times outlines an 18% drop in foreign students, mainly in graduate programs.

What the Trump Administration has done has made America seem unwelcoming. Our racist VP, who feels Heritage Americans are the only ones who should have agency, is part of the Stephen Miller plan to Make America White Again.

America never was white, and by 2045 it will be a majority minority country. America is about immigration; we are successfully melting the population together (mostly) Muslims and Orthodox Jews, not so much. Our culture clashes with their religious values. But absent that, we are very good at incorporating immigrants of all sorts.

Steven Mintz's avatar

The history is more complicated than you suggest.

The United States began policing its borders long before 1965. Early enforcement was directed in significant part against Chinese immigrants seeking to circumvent the Chinese Exclusion Act. The Border Patrol was established in 1924, and unlawful entry became a criminal offense in 1929. The absence of numerical quotas on Mexican immigration did not mean an open border.

American policy was also deeply contradictory. Employers depended on Mexican labor, while the government alternated between recruiting workers and deporting them. The Bracero Program (1942–1964) was a temporary guest-worker program, not a pathway to permanent immigration or citizenship. Its termination eliminated a major legal route for Mexican workers even as American demand for their labor continued.

Your account also largely overlooks refugee policy. The United States admitted displaced Europeans after World War II, favored refugees fleeing Communist regimes during the Cold War, and established a broader refugee and asylum system in 1980. Yet Salvadorans and Guatemalans fleeing civil wars often faced much greater obstacles to asylum than Cubans and other refugees from Communist countries.

Nor should Hispanic immigration be treated as a single phenomenon. Mexican migration was closely tied to labor demand, wage differences, and family networks. Central American migration was also shaped by civil wars, political persecution, violence, and instability, sometimes involving American foreign policy. Mexican immigration slowed sharply after 2007, while migration from Central America increased. More recently, Venezuelans, Haitians, Cubans, and others have further changed the composition of migration.

Finally, tougher border enforcement had unintended consequences. Mexican workers who had previously traveled back and forth increasingly settled permanently rather than risk repeated crossings.

So while the 1965 law did not deliberately encourage mass Mexican immigration, it is misleading to suggest that subsequent migration was largely unrelated to government policy.

The larger story is how immigration restrictions, labor demand, refugee policies, foreign intervention, and border enforcement interacted—often in contradictory ways—to shape who came to the United States, why they came, and whether they stayed.

Steven Mintz, The University of Texas at Austin

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt's avatar

If I wanted to know what ChatGPT thought was a good response to this, I have my own subscription. (But it's nice to discover that the Substack Pangram integration works on comments too.)

evan bear's avatar

Just as a gut reaction regarding family unification, I kind of think you're more likely to succeed and assimilate here if you have extended family to support you and be comfortable around. Just like you're more likely to do well here if you come with a spouse. If you come here as a lone 25-year-old rando from Nepal or whatever, you're going to be awfully isolated and lonely even if you have a work visa and a job. Maybe you'll find a community of people from your country of origin who can ease your adjustment, but maybe you won't.

bloodknight's avatar

But how do you avoid ethnic enclaves? I mean, we're not that likely to end up with the Haredi/Amish situations again, but it is worth increasing the friction of not assimilating. We're still damn good at this and Spanish speakers are easy to assimilate regardless.

evan bear's avatar

The Haredi and Amish are oddball religious sects. The typical ethnic community is more like Indians in Central Jersey or Armenians in Los Angeles or Vietnamese in DC/Houston. I guess those are "ethnic enclaves" in a sense that if you drive around in Edison you'll go down streets with a bunch of Indian restaurants, and there are Hindu temples that people worship at, and middle-aged men will form cricket leagues at the local park. But they also have regular jobs and interact with non-Indians and their kids go to college like anyone else.

evan bear's avatar

I guess I would add that you'd want to limit family reunification to situations where the initial immigrants are doing well here. Family members tend to be similar, so if the initial immigrants are doing poorly, then there's no reason why you'd want to bring over their siblings or cousins. But if the initial family who comes here does well, then their brother's or sister's family is more likely to do well too. I don't think it's a terrible basis for giving them a bit of preference.

Oliver's avatar

Maybe but that is an argument against immigration, not an argument to refuse to apply immigration laws to relatives of immigrants.

evan bear's avatar

I'm not sure if you understood my point because this reply doesn't make any sense as a response to anything I said.

Oliver's avatar

If immigration is a bad experience because people are away from family and their culture then they shouldn't emigrate, the answer is not to bring their whole family with them.

Andrew Gawthorpe's avatar

I'm teaching a class on this precise topic today and while I started reading this post thinking I'd be able to make some smart-assed pedantic comment at the end, the post is so good that I've got nothing!

Thomas L. Hutcheson's avatar

"Obviously, though, Republicans aren’t going to flip and give Democrats what they want on this. The old concept was that a deal would include lots of measures on border security, but Republicans aren’t going to want that now, because they’ve already achieved what they wanted on border security through partisan bills."

This makes it sound like Democrats wanted large numbers of illegal immigrants, which is what Republcans claim. My understanding was that Democrats wanted low cost, humane treatment of people trying to enter illegally and in 2021- refused to prevent claiming asylum to allow "legal" immigration.

What neither party has tried to do is try to get a lot more immigrants like Huang and Musk and the guy who came from India and got rich running a chian of motels in the Midwest, and the Latino that developed a nice home improvement business in MD.

As for interior enforcement, it's to do two things a) remove people to entred illegally and by their behavior -- getting in trouble with the law -- indicate that they are not contributing to the economy and b) adding to the incentive (which should be mainly just border control). But it's costly and should be pretty limited or the costs will exceed the benefits.

Oliver's avatar

Is there a useful distinction between being pro illegal immigration and wanting humane treatment of migrants and easy access to the asylum system?

There is a similar dynamic in lots of areas, homelessness is the obvious example where the left wants humane treatment of homeless people and restrictions on unfair policing practices that target them.

Oliver's avatar

How bad is family reunification as a system in America?

In the UK it is a farce with the average Pakistani worker bringing in six family members and the average Cameroonian care worker bringing in 15!!!! family members (small sample size).

Oliver's avatar

There is a somebody who decided to increase immigration in the 80s and 90s, but it wasn't Congress or the Executive, it was farmers and officials in border states who wanted labour that would work at wages below what Americans would demand and those who tolerared that illegality. A policy continued by Trump who still refuses to fine farmers and other employers who hire illegal labour.