Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Oliver's avatar

There is a somebody who decided to increase immigration in the 80s and 90s, but it wasn't Congress or the Executive, it was farmers and officials in border states who wanted labour that would work at wages below what Americans would demand and those who tolerared that illegality. A policy continued by Trump who still refuses to fine farmers and other employers who hire illegal labour.

Steven Mintz's avatar

The history is more complicated than you suggest.

The United States began policing its borders long before 1965. Early enforcement was directed in significant part against Chinese immigrants seeking to circumvent the Chinese Exclusion Act. The Border Patrol was established in 1924, and unlawful entry became a criminal offense in 1929. The absence of numerical quotas on Mexican immigration did not mean an open border.

American policy was also deeply contradictory. Employers depended on Mexican labor, while the government alternated between recruiting workers and deporting them. The Bracero Program (1942–1964) was a temporary guest-worker program, not a pathway to permanent immigration or citizenship. Its termination eliminated a major legal route for Mexican workers even as American demand for their labor continued.

Your account also largely overlooks refugee policy. The United States admitted displaced Europeans after World War II, favored refugees fleeing Communist regimes during the Cold War, and established a broader refugee and asylum system in 1980. Yet Salvadorans and Guatemalans fleeing civil wars often faced much greater obstacles to asylum than Cubans and other refugees from Communist countries.

Nor should Hispanic immigration be treated as a single phenomenon. Mexican migration was closely tied to labor demand, wage differences, and family networks. Central American migration was also shaped by civil wars, political persecution, violence, and instability, sometimes involving American foreign policy. Mexican immigration slowed sharply after 2007, while migration from Central America increased. More recently, Venezuelans, Haitians, Cubans, and others have further changed the composition of migration.

Finally, tougher border enforcement had unintended consequences. Mexican workers who had previously traveled back and forth increasingly settled permanently rather than risk repeated crossings.

So while the 1965 law did not deliberately encourage mass Mexican immigration, it is misleading to suggest that subsequent migration was largely unrelated to government policy.

The larger story is how immigration restrictions, labor demand, refugee policies, foreign intervention, and border enforcement interacted—often in contradictory ways—to shape who came to the United States, why they came, and whether they stayed.

Steven Mintz, The University of Texas at Austin

14 more comments...

Ready for more?