There are also 2x the number of residency slots as US MD graduates so that doesn’t really seem to be the bottleneck (more residency slots would allow more international doctors to come practice since many of them fail to match, but it’d be even better if they could skip residency and there are also visa issues that would be lower-hanging fruit). Ultimately the doctor shortage in parts of the country comes from the fact that being a doctor is a really hard job that most people don’t want, and doctors can reliably make enough money to comfortably live anywhere yet are in demand everywhere, so people in that position generally don’t like to live in some of the more backwards parts of the country.
A lot of the biggest billionaire companies do have a ton of market power and charge monopoly prices. Two big examples of this: Apple’s 30% cut of App Store fees and Meta/Google’s ad prices. Consumers don’t pay these directly so you might not notice but they are subject to antitrust litigation all around the world because they drive up costs for all the businesses that use them and ultimately do feed into consumer costs.
It's weird to have a whole post on Monopoly and not mention the anticompetitive practices of Hasbro, or how the Free Parking square is a metaphor for YIMBYism. Also strange to tab over here after just reading about the proposed upcoming SCP movies, from studios...A24 and Neon. Spoopy coincidence!
Twitter isn't real life, but I'm told that the old version of bluechecks essentially functioned as a form of "journalist licensing regime". As for salon standards, people sometimes dissemble about how they don't want just anyone waving a straight razor around their face...but I did once hear a tricky argument to refute non-combatively, I guess call it the "black barber argument"? That is, people with particularly tricky to service hair already struggle with finding competent clippers, so There Oughtta Be A Law requiring cultural competency as a barberous baseline. I have no idea how the politically-savvy popularist neoliberal defuses that sequitur without choking on throat-clearing.
NIMBY-ism is not about barriers to_entry_. A lot of regulation just seemt be acretions onto a kernal of senible concern. No doubt this is abetted by insiders trying to create barriers to entry, but the political economy of that explanation does not feel right. [Is there a powerful nail salon cartel that lobbies for restrictive traning regimes?] No doubt, too, that regulators (self interestedly, but not necesarily corruptly) seek to increase the scope of their regulations. And all against an environment of defalt zero sum thinking.
Especially given that car dealership owners almost always vote Republican, can someone explain why there hasn’t been more of an effort to roll back the laws preventing most car companies from sellling direct to consumers?
There's a ripe opportunity here for a silly article along the lines of "Deal Cars For America", urging people with liberal beliefs and voting records to go into the business of car dealerships. Be the small business change you want to see!
Probably the degrowth enviros would also oppose such changes for making cars more accessible. Like it's good for EVs right now, but the equilibrium of only Tesla and Rivian selling direct while Gerald Ford et al can't, well, that's not really stable.
One reason, I think, is that it wouldn't be very popular and car dealerships are a powerful lobby. They are small businesses in your community that sponsor your kids' little league teams. Somewhat relatedly, I remember Matt writing about Elizabeth Warren pushing through the banking bill under Obama, and it was easy to roll the big investment banks but they were forced to make big concessions when trying to regulate small banks, which were a much more powerful lobby.
The other tricky thing with the Paramount/Warner merger is market definition. Other movie studios are arguably competing in the same market. So is Netflix, even though most of its movies are released direct to streaming. Fine, you can still make an argument that the merger would increase market concentration by an unacceptable amount.
But what about YouTube? Or Instagram Reels/TikTok? If you group them into the same marker as Paramount and Warner then it looks really unconcentrated. If you don’t then it looks much more concentrated. This also gets tricky because YouTube and Instagram and TikTok make their money from ads rather than charging consumers for subscriptions, which makes it hard to calculate diversion ratios based on price increases. (I’m sure there’s a way to do it but I didn’t get that far in my coursework.)
Anyways I find this stuff very interesting personally so I think over Thanksgiving I will write up a blog post that tries to explain how to estimate demand and supply curves and simulate the effect of a merger in both plain English and econometrics.
There are also 2x the number of residency slots as US MD graduates so that doesn’t really seem to be the bottleneck (more residency slots would allow more international doctors to come practice since many of them fail to match, but it’d be even better if they could skip residency and there are also visa issues that would be lower-hanging fruit). Ultimately the doctor shortage in parts of the country comes from the fact that being a doctor is a really hard job that most people don’t want, and doctors can reliably make enough money to comfortably live anywhere yet are in demand everywhere, so people in that position generally don’t like to live in some of the more backwards parts of the country.
A lot of the biggest billionaire companies do have a ton of market power and charge monopoly prices. Two big examples of this: Apple’s 30% cut of App Store fees and Meta/Google’s ad prices. Consumers don’t pay these directly so you might not notice but they are subject to antitrust litigation all around the world because they drive up costs for all the businesses that use them and ultimately do feed into consumer costs.
It's weird to have a whole post on Monopoly and not mention the anticompetitive practices of Hasbro, or how the Free Parking square is a metaphor for YIMBYism. Also strange to tab over here after just reading about the proposed upcoming SCP movies, from studios...A24 and Neon. Spoopy coincidence!
Twitter isn't real life, but I'm told that the old version of bluechecks essentially functioned as a form of "journalist licensing regime". As for salon standards, people sometimes dissemble about how they don't want just anyone waving a straight razor around their face...but I did once hear a tricky argument to refute non-combatively, I guess call it the "black barber argument"? That is, people with particularly tricky to service hair already struggle with finding competent clippers, so There Oughtta Be A Law requiring cultural competency as a barberous baseline. I have no idea how the politically-savvy popularist neoliberal defuses that sequitur without choking on throat-clearing.
NIMBY-ism is not about barriers to_entry_. A lot of regulation just seemt be acretions onto a kernal of senible concern. No doubt this is abetted by insiders trying to create barriers to entry, but the political economy of that explanation does not feel right. [Is there a powerful nail salon cartel that lobbies for restrictive traning regimes?] No doubt, too, that regulators (self interestedly, but not necesarily corruptly) seek to increase the scope of their regulations. And all against an environment of defalt zero sum thinking.
Still the whole oucome is a bit mysterious.
Especially given that car dealership owners almost always vote Republican, can someone explain why there hasn’t been more of an effort to roll back the laws preventing most car companies from sellling direct to consumers?
There's a ripe opportunity here for a silly article along the lines of "Deal Cars For America", urging people with liberal beliefs and voting records to go into the business of car dealerships. Be the small business change you want to see!
Probably the degrowth enviros would also oppose such changes for making cars more accessible. Like it's good for EVs right now, but the equilibrium of only Tesla and Rivian selling direct while Gerald Ford et al can't, well, that's not really stable.
One reason, I think, is that it wouldn't be very popular and car dealerships are a powerful lobby. They are small businesses in your community that sponsor your kids' little league teams. Somewhat relatedly, I remember Matt writing about Elizabeth Warren pushing through the banking bill under Obama, and it was easy to roll the big investment banks but they were forced to make big concessions when trying to regulate small banks, which were a much more powerful lobby.
The other tricky thing with the Paramount/Warner merger is market definition. Other movie studios are arguably competing in the same market. So is Netflix, even though most of its movies are released direct to streaming. Fine, you can still make an argument that the merger would increase market concentration by an unacceptable amount.
But what about YouTube? Or Instagram Reels/TikTok? If you group them into the same marker as Paramount and Warner then it looks really unconcentrated. If you don’t then it looks much more concentrated. This also gets tricky because YouTube and Instagram and TikTok make their money from ads rather than charging consumers for subscriptions, which makes it hard to calculate diversion ratios based on price increases. (I’m sure there’s a way to do it but I didn’t get that far in my coursework.)
Anyways I find this stuff very interesting personally so I think over Thanksgiving I will write up a blog post that tries to explain how to estimate demand and supply curves and simulate the effect of a merger in both plain English and econometrics.