Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Casey's avatar

I am surprised at how cynical the comments have started off this morning.

Facts are Trump has no problem killing civilians as long as they're the right civilians, he will look the other way as Putin eviscerates Ukraine and quashes what's left of the civil liberty of his own people, and as Xi finishes the cultural and to some degree genetic eradication of Uyhhur Muslims and prepares to annihilate a functioning democracy at his doorstep, he will empower right wing nutjobs to diminish LGTBQ rights and home and abroad, he will corrode the freedom of the press and undermine the integrity of our elections (and let's be real, if America slips out of democracy there will be backsliding in other democracies too), and he will once again seek to crush legal immigration while maximizing the cruelty we inflict on illegal immigrants.

Biden does not and will not do those things. Anyone who seriously argues otherwise is delusional. This is not that complicated.

Expand full comment
Dilan Esper's avatar

The broader point here is right, but I really don't think leading with the selectivity of state department reports and quitting the UN human rights panel is really appropriate here.

Despite what Matt's NGO sources say, the State Department is fatally compromised by realpolitik and always has been, and the UN spends a lot of time not actually doing anything about human rights. Plus the charges of bias against Israel at the UN are well founded, as we have seen since 10/7. Many people in the UN/NGO/human rights lawyers sector expend massive amounts of time on the Israel issue in comparison to what it deserves, and basically buy into the "settler colonialist state" narrative and think Israel shouldn't exist.

At the end of the day the US isn't ever going to be a human rights leader, because we are a powerful country and powerful countries do things like ally with Saudi Arabia due to energy needs and placate China to keep consumer goods cheap and in order to work on global governance issues.

But what we can do- and where this piece scores- is not engage in massive human rights abuses ourselves, and Biden has been a massive improvement on that front.

Expand full comment
394 more comments...

No posts