30:35 "Is there a case that the anti-abortion movement was never as much truly about abortion as it claimed to be, that it was about cultural grievances?"
Well, there's evidence that the anti-abortion issue was a substitute for objection to the loss of tax exempt status of segregationist schools and colleges. See _Bad Faith:
You started the Politix podcast with a joke about Greenland being a fever dream and it reminded me of something.
I was running a 40 degree fever in September 2001 and I woke up late that morning (remember im five timezones from NYC) and switched on the TV and saw the first tower burning. I watched the second plane hit.
Obviously the news coverage doesn't get replayed and it's not like I can ever ask people for the details of what happened on 9/11. My memories are a mess for obvious reasons, so I can't tell whether the details I remember are real or fever dream.
One I'm fairly sure was a fever dream was seeing someone jump from one tower above the fire to the other tower below the fire.
I am indifferent to the question of right about Trump (since subjective and half-emotional).
The real question is What Breaks Through to ensure that Trump is max-lame-ducked and co-Partisans start to throw him under a proverbial bus.
It's self-evident that the Dem core College-Educated-Professional-Class is already pre-sold on Threat to Democracy. They hardly need more convincing. So serving more of that is self-indulgence largely.
It's also equally clear from the track record that in high-participation elections where low-propensity voters are higher precentage that messages that actually reach this more working class / not professional class / not/less college educated needs a different pitch to win over and bring comfort so they return to Democrats.
More self-indulgence and more appeal to the already hair-on-fire LEfties is repeating 2024.
Trump is indeed since he has no partisan guard rails in Trump II much more dangerous than anticipated by many (me I include however pessimistic I was about him).
But congratualting myself over thinking and saying Trump would be bad doesn't get me anywhere in peeling off that 15-30% (depending on the specific geography) of floating votes that have migrated back and forth.
I was amused because matt did the same thing on either a substack live or a podcast (it might have been politix) not so long ago ... now that you've explained it, it finally makes sense!
What prediction based on “Trump will do the dumbest/most corrupt/most illiberal/generally destructive thing” (the standard Resistance Lib heuristic) did *not* come true?
Seems to me like people assuming the worst of Trump got it right and their voices should be weighted more heavily in predictions while those who said “it will be fine” got it wrong and their voices need to be reduced in weight.
As is very common, Resist Libs are correct on the problem but mistaken on the solution. I think there’s a large overlap between Resist Libs who want to #resist everything Trump does and Do Something Libs who don’t understand that the party controlling 0/3 branches of government doesn’t actually have many levers it can pull.
Resist Libs correctly see how bad Trump is but incorrectly think that pointing out his flaws is necessary and sufficient electoral strategy. Too often they then get frustrated with the electorate for failing to see the obvious, and give up on the idea of persuading them on other issues.
Is it possible to couch this only in "norm breaking" and not in policy? Like many others here (I think), I'm deeply concerned people who were right about Trump all along will come to the conclusion that because of ICE's cruelty, we should just do away with the border.
I mean, as a matter of actual public policy independent of people's moronic views about the issue, we SHOULD do away with the border. Borders as lines on the sand are as archaic and useless as plate mail. Every dollar we spend on so-called border protection is just pure wastage, even worse than burying it in holes since at least if you bury the money in a hole someone could conceivably dig it up again.
I get that people don't want to hear this and have all these psychosexual hangups about "the border" as a mental construct, but between you, me and the Staten Island ferry...
RIGHT: Trump's norm breaking and ill effects for democracy
IFFY: Trump's motivations; ResistLibs love the idea that Putin has embarassing "kompromat" on Trump that he uses to make Trump dance like a puppet. That Trump is greedy and unprincipled is sufficient to explain his behavior without a grand conspiracy.
WRONG: misunderstanding the stakes, hoping with some glee that "we" get to do leftist extremism in exchange without getting that most voters perceived Trump to be moderate, centering identity while insisting at all times that America is the worst/most racist/most sexist/most transphobic country on earth (especially if that's true, it implies the strategy is to de-activate people's sense of identity).
I want to be careful not to No True Scotsman, so I’ll say that SOME resistance libs were in favor of leftist extremism. But not all! In fact, I’d wager that the people who most supported leftist overreach were the ones who were allergic to saying Trump was uniquely bad.
To some limited extent, sure, but if you're truly interested in assessing whose predictions to take seriously you probably want to look at their full track record, and not over-index on one particular set of calls.
Very true! I certainly wouldn’t look to someone’s track record on predicting Trump’s behavior to date to get a sense of their ability to pick equities.
But I would heavily index them when it comes to forward-looking statements on what Trump will do.
I find his annoyance with liberals itself extremely annoying. But I think Nate is an excellent writer, and I appreciate his analytical chops. He gets a lot right.
Silver's takes might not be deep analysis, but his poll models remain the best in the game. And I think he's really fun in the podcast/substack-live format. I'd love to see MattY do more stuff with him.
Nate's basically the dividing line in my personal 'useful but sometimes wrong' and 'just wrong' views of anti-woke centrists. Sullivan drifted back toward the useful but sometimes wrong side w/ his forceful opposition to the ICE stuff. I just hope no transgender person wins a sports event in the next few weeks.
I read Zaid’s main point as: the left needs to learn that centering race in politics is likely to backfire. It’s true that some white voters are so racist they can’t be reached. Others (many of whom are poor or struggling) have more malleable politics. They might support policies that help all poor and working people, if they’re not framed/sold as benefits for nonwhites (the framing that many college elite Ds seem to think is essential or most persuasive).
There's a synthesis available here where Trump "likes" (to the extent that word even makes sense in the context of a psychopath) people he can shake down for their assets and poor brown people, on average, have no assets so he has total contempt for them.
30:35 "Is there a case that the anti-abortion movement was never as much truly about abortion as it claimed to be, that it was about cultural grievances?"
Well, there's evidence that the anti-abortion issue was a substitute for objection to the loss of tax exempt status of segregationist schools and colleges. See _Bad Faith:
Race and the Rise of the Religious Right_ by Randall Balmer, and https://www.americanprogress.org/article/the-religious-right-wasnt-created-to-battle-abortion
I think these two underrate how much their Twitter posting undermines their "calm cool and collected" substacking.
Aren't we supposed to get a transcript?
You started the Politix podcast with a joke about Greenland being a fever dream and it reminded me of something.
I was running a 40 degree fever in September 2001 and I woke up late that morning (remember im five timezones from NYC) and switched on the TV and saw the first tower burning. I watched the second plane hit.
Obviously the news coverage doesn't get replayed and it's not like I can ever ask people for the details of what happened on 9/11. My memories are a mess for obvious reasons, so I can't tell whether the details I remember are real or fever dream.
One I'm fairly sure was a fever dream was seeing someone jump from one tower above the fire to the other tower below the fire.
I am indifferent to the question of right about Trump (since subjective and half-emotional).
The real question is What Breaks Through to ensure that Trump is max-lame-ducked and co-Partisans start to throw him under a proverbial bus.
It's self-evident that the Dem core College-Educated-Professional-Class is already pre-sold on Threat to Democracy. They hardly need more convincing. So serving more of that is self-indulgence largely.
It's also equally clear from the track record that in high-participation elections where low-propensity voters are higher precentage that messages that actually reach this more working class / not professional class / not/less college educated needs a different pitch to win over and bring comfort so they return to Democrats.
More self-indulgence and more appeal to the already hair-on-fire LEfties is repeating 2024.
Trump is indeed since he has no partisan guard rails in Trump II much more dangerous than anticipated by many (me I include however pessimistic I was about him).
But congratualting myself over thinking and saying Trump would be bad doesn't get me anywhere in peeling off that 15-30% (depending on the specific geography) of floating votes that have migrated back and forth.
I’d love it if the two of you had a podcast.
The whole world wants to know if you're going to be revising and extending the comments about 50 minutes in.
MY continues his quest to make Eric Adams police comissioner by sheer force of will ...
I believe there was a silent apostrophe, “Erik Adams’ police commissioner.” But yes, that caused a bit of a double take.
That's what I meant! I actually went to high school and college with Jessica Tisch and am aware that she is not Eric Adams.
I was amused because matt did the same thing on either a substack live or a podcast (it might have been politix) not so long ago ... now that you've explained it, it finally makes sense!
What prediction based on “Trump will do the dumbest/most corrupt/most illiberal/generally destructive thing” (the standard Resistance Lib heuristic) did *not* come true?
Seems to me like people assuming the worst of Trump got it right and their voices should be weighted more heavily in predictions while those who said “it will be fine” got it wrong and their voices need to be reduced in weight.
As is very common, Resist Libs are correct on the problem but mistaken on the solution. I think there’s a large overlap between Resist Libs who want to #resist everything Trump does and Do Something Libs who don’t understand that the party controlling 0/3 branches of government doesn’t actually have many levers it can pull.
Resist Libs correctly see how bad Trump is but incorrectly think that pointing out his flaws is necessary and sufficient electoral strategy. Too often they then get frustrated with the electorate for failing to see the obvious, and give up on the idea of persuading them on other issues.
Is it possible to couch this only in "norm breaking" and not in policy? Like many others here (I think), I'm deeply concerned people who were right about Trump all along will come to the conclusion that because of ICE's cruelty, we should just do away with the border.
I mean, as a matter of actual public policy independent of people's moronic views about the issue, we SHOULD do away with the border. Borders as lines on the sand are as archaic and useless as plate mail. Every dollar we spend on so-called border protection is just pure wastage, even worse than burying it in holes since at least if you bury the money in a hole someone could conceivably dig it up again.
I get that people don't want to hear this and have all these psychosexual hangups about "the border" as a mental construct, but between you, me and the Staten Island ferry...
Resistance Lib track record:
RIGHT: Trump's norm breaking and ill effects for democracy
IFFY: Trump's motivations; ResistLibs love the idea that Putin has embarassing "kompromat" on Trump that he uses to make Trump dance like a puppet. That Trump is greedy and unprincipled is sufficient to explain his behavior without a grand conspiracy.
WRONG: misunderstanding the stakes, hoping with some glee that "we" get to do leftist extremism in exchange without getting that most voters perceived Trump to be moderate, centering identity while insisting at all times that America is the worst/most racist/most sexist/most transphobic country on earth (especially if that's true, it implies the strategy is to de-activate people's sense of identity).
You’re conflating resistance lib with stupid woke stuff.
The prototypical Resistance Lib is extremely woke.
I want to be careful not to No True Scotsman, so I’ll say that SOME resistance libs were in favor of leftist extremism. But not all! In fact, I’d wager that the people who most supported leftist overreach were the ones who were allergic to saying Trump was uniquely bad.
To some limited extent, sure, but if you're truly interested in assessing whose predictions to take seriously you probably want to look at their full track record, and not over-index on one particular set of calls.
Very true! I certainly wouldn’t look to someone’s track record on predicting Trump’s behavior to date to get a sense of their ability to pick equities.
But I would heavily index them when it comes to forward-looking statements on what Trump will do.
Sad that Matt did this. Silver is a complete joke with no new or interesting ideas over the past couple years. Just visceral "heterodoxy".
I find his annoyance with liberals itself extremely annoying. But I think Nate is an excellent writer, and I appreciate his analytical chops. He gets a lot right.
Silver's takes might not be deep analysis, but his poll models remain the best in the game. And I think he's really fun in the podcast/substack-live format. I'd love to see MattY do more stuff with him.
@VK Could you say more what the point of disagreement you have with Silver is? In terms of issues or attitudes/behaviors?
Nate's basically the dividing line in my personal 'useful but sometimes wrong' and 'just wrong' views of anti-woke centrists. Sullivan drifted back toward the useful but sometimes wrong side w/ his forceful opposition to the ICE stuff. I just hope no transgender person wins a sports event in the next few weeks.
I read Zaid’s main point as: the left needs to learn that centering race in politics is likely to backfire. It’s true that some white voters are so racist they can’t be reached. Others (many of whom are poor or struggling) have more malleable politics. They might support policies that help all poor and working people, if they’re not framed/sold as benefits for nonwhites (the framing that many college elite Ds seem to think is essential or most persuasive).
There's a synthesis available here where Trump "likes" (to the extent that word even makes sense in the context of a psychopath) people he can shake down for their assets and poor brown people, on average, have no assets so he has total contempt for them.