Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Thomas L. Hutcheson's avatar

Got to stick up for my old macroeconomics teacher Arthur Okun. I don't think it is fair to say the thought all transfer buckets were very leaky. It is just true that there are better and worse ways to transfer income. A higher EITC, jiggled to be more like a wage subsidy than a family income supplement, is better than minimum wage, etc.

Expand full comment
MagellanNH's avatar

I agree we should allow more skilled immigrants into the country.

I can't wrap my head around the Democrats' insistence on tying better immigration policy to dealing with the undocumented folks already here. I get why they do it politically, but it's not like the harm caused by their stubbornness only affects Republicans. I would argue teaming up with Republicans on this would increase the Democrats' vote share. This is another case where Matt's right that the Democratic approach to Republican election theft seems to be to ensure Republicans can easily win fair and square.

On the Republican side, I see very little support for making it tougher for companies to hire undocumented workers. As I understand it, illegal entry is tightly coupled with job prospects across the border. Better enforcement of rules against hiring undocumented workers would drop illegal entry significantly.

So basically, neither side really cares about regaining control over who comes into the country. Both sides seem more interested in scoring political points and supporting their donors' financial interests than solving any real problems.

Expand full comment
141 more comments...

No posts