Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clement Pappas's avatar

True story: I asked my 10 year old niece what she learned in school this year. “Our country was really mean to the Native Americans. We took their land and killed them.” Learn anything else about the US? “Yes, we still use mean stereotypes of the native Americans.” Anything else about America? “No that’s it.” Now, perhaps she was taught more, but that was her takeaway and it was 100% of what she retained about her country. She happens to go to a very nice private school in a major city.

This is what conservatives are against. These kids are being taught a purely oppressor-victim narrative of the country with zero context of the greater success of the American project. They don’t seem to learn that despite all its warts, this was truly a revolutionary project in terms of human freedom and equality and is essentially unparalleled in human history. That context is wiped away and we teach only the negative parts while forgetting that those very negative parts, while mostly an exception in America, were generally the norm for most people all over the globe for most of human history.

If we teach a generation of kids that our country has been a history of pure evil and oppression with no redeeming qualities, I guess progressives think the kids will remedy the oppression. Conservatives see a generation of radicals that will hold deeply anti-American sentiments with no sense of there being anything valuable worth preserving. This, of course, can only lead to the decay of the nation.

There just has to be a balance. We have many things worth preserving while still having things we need to improve upon. Reasonable people should be able to agree on this.

Expand full comment
Ray Hashem's avatar

Look around your society. All told, it’s a pretty good society. It’s better than virtually every society that’s ever existed. Certainly, it’s far better than Bangladesh, where my dad grew up. Fundamentally, (American) conservatism posits that (1) we don’t really understand how our society got to be as successful as it is; and (2) that we should be extremely careful about changing it because we risk breaking it. It’s the applied version of Chesterton’s Fence.

What conservatives fear about a liberal retelling of history, that focuses only on the negatives and not on the positives, is that it will convince kids that the system as a whole needs upheaval and change. And conservatives think that’s bad not because it’s bad for conservatives, but because they think that upheaval would be bad for America.

Concrete example: I’m a conservative precisely because I’m an immigrant of color. When I look around America I see people with virtues lacking in the people back home, and system of government that’s produced remarkable stability and prosperity. In particular I see a system that has enabled many successive generations of immigrants to achieve parity with the original Anglo Saxon founders of the country, including non-white immigrants like Latinos and Asians: https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353.

The success of America at being a multi-ethnic democracy is unparalleled. Even in Europe with its robust welfare states immigrants who look like me are stuck in generational poverty. But in America we’re richer than white people!

I’m afraid of you liberals breaking that.

Expand full comment
515 more comments...

No posts